Doctors and patient groups have called for a review of NHS England’s list cleansing exercise after concerns were raised around its potential impact on patients and GP practices.
The British Medical Association (BMA) have said that GP practices are seeing “an unprecedented acceleration in patient list cleaning”, leading to “rapid list size reductions, unexpected reductions in funding, and potential patient safety risks, particularly for vulnerable populations.”
They have called for an immediate halt to the exercise, which has seen over a million patients removed from GP lists since the start of the exercise in November 2025.
The Labour MP for Putney, Fleur Anderson, raised the issue in Parliament last month.
She said: “Putney GPs have told me that in the last six months, 344,000 patients have been taken off GP lists, 44% of whom are in London.
“Some are taken off after not responding to a single letter.”
The exercise expands on the existing system of removing ‘ghost’, or inactive patients, by sending correspondence to selected patients asking them to confirm their registration status.
Previously, they were given six months to respond, but this has now been reduced to three.
Patient groups say it appears to be targeting a much larger number of people, and seems to have disproportionately affected the most deprived practices.
Dr Lisa Harrod-Rothwell, CEO of Londonwide LMCs (Local Medical Committees), the representative body for NHS GPs in the capital, said the process “risks de-registering many vulnerable patients who still live near their practice and are in particular need of GP care.”
She said: “People experiencing homelessness, temporary accommodation, frequent moves, language barriers, disability, frailty, cognitive impairment, digital exclusion or under coercive control may be less likely to receive, understand or able to respond to official correspondence.”
The Doctors Association UK has written an open letter to NHS England asking to pause the programme “until its safety, accuracy and impact have been independently reviewed”.
Doctors of the World, an organisation supporting patients from vulnerable groups, have also called for a review.
Valentina D’Orazio, their Senior Policy & Advocacy Manager, said the exercise has been done at “an incredibly fast pace and with unclear guidelines” and goes “beyond administrative practicalities”, affecting healthcare, risking widening health inequalities, and putting more pressure on GP practices.
She said: “It definitely becomes a patient safety issue because people will not know that they’ve been deregistered until they need medical help.
“In the meantime, they may miss out on screening, or reminders.”
In a letter to GPs and clinical directors, NHS England outlined safeguards they say are in place to protect patients, adding they “will continue to talk to stakeholders as this work progresses and will review the evidence, monitor impacts and ensure that appropriate safeguards remain in place.”
Harros-Rothwell advised patients to respond to correspondence asking them to confirm whether they need to remain registered with their GP practice.
For patients who have already de-registered because of this process, she said: “Remember, your GP practice did not choose to remove you and will happily re-register you.”
She added: “GP practices are funded per registered patient. Stripping away this funding may result in local practices having to lose hardworking staff or close altogether.
“NHS England say the money clawed back will be spent in general practice, but has not been clear about how and whether London will lose out overall.”
NHS England has now introduced a pilot, to ‘support patient list maintenance’, where patients are given the option for respond to communication via text/SMS.
A spokesperson for NHS South West London said: “It is important that GP patient lists are up to date and accurate. We are keeping under review the impact of NHS England’s GP list cleansing process on GP practices in the South West.”
NHS England were approached for comment.
Featured image credit: Zainab Hussain






Join the discussion